gendal

README

About gendal

gendal is a command-line tool to generate Go code based on a database schema or a custom query. It is based on a fork of the xo repository.

gendal works by using database metadata and SQL introspection queries to discover the types and relationships contained within a schema, and applying a standard set of base (or customized) Go templates against the discovered relationships.

Currently, gendal can generate types for tables, enums, stored procedures, and custom SQL queries for PostgreSQL, MySQL, Oracle, Microsoft SQL Server, CockroachDB, and SQLite3 databases.

NOTE: While the code generated by gendal is production quality, it is not the goal, nor the intention for gendal to be a "silver bullet," nor to completely eliminate the manual authoring of SQL / Go code.

Database Feature Support

The following is a matrix of the feature support for each database:

	PostgreSQL	MySQL	Oracle	Microsoft SQL Server	SQLite	CockroachDB
Models	✅	✅	✅	✅	✅	✅
Primary Keys	✅	✅	✅	✅	✅	✅
Foreign Keys	✅	✅	✅	✅	✅	✅
Indexes	✅	✅	✅	✅	✅	✅
Stored Procs	✅	✅
ENUM types	✅	✅
Custom types	✅

Installation

Install goimports dependency (if not already installed):

$ go get -u golang.org/x/tools/cmd/goimports

Then, install in the usual Go way:

$ go get -u github.com/

# install with oracle support (see notes below)
$ go get -tags oracle -u github.com/turnkey-commerce/gendal

NOTE: Go 1.6+ is needed for installing gendal from source, as it makes use of the trim template syntax in Go templates, which is not compatible with previous versions of Go. However, code generated by gendal should compile with Go 1.3+.

Quickstart

The following is a quick overview of using gendal on the command-line:

# change to project directory
$ cd $GOPATH/src/path/to/project

# make an output directory
$ mkdir -p models

# generate code for a postgres schema
$ gendal pgsql://user:pass@host/dbname -o models

# generate code for a Microsoft SQL schema using a custom template directory (see notes below)
$ mkdir -p mssqlmodels
$ gendal mysql://user:pass@host/dbname -o mssqlmodels --template-path /path/to/custom/templates

# generate code for a custom SQL query for postgres
$ gendal pgsql://user:pass@host/dbname -N -M -B -T AuthorResult -o models/ << ENDSQL
SELECT
  a.name::varchar AS name,
  b.type::integer AS my_type
FROM authors a
  INNER JOIN authortypes b ON a.id = b.author_id
WHERE
  a.id = %%authorID int%%
LIMIT %%limit int%%
ENDSQL

# build generated code
$ go build ./models/
$ go build ./mssqlmodels/

# do standard go install
$ go install ./models/
$ go install ./mssqlmodels/

Command Line Options

Following are gendal's command-line arguments and options. These options can also be set using a configuration file.

$ gendal --help
usage: gendal [--verbose] [--schema SCHEMA] [--out OUT] [--append] [--suffix SUFFIX] [--single-file] [--package PACKAGE] [--custom-type-package CUSTOM-TYPE-PACKAGE] [--int32-type INT32-TYPE] [--uint32-type UINT32-TYPE] [--ignore-fields IGNORE-FIELDS] [--ignore-tables IGNORE-TABLES] [--fk-mode FK-MODE] [--use-index-names] [--use-reversed-enum-const-names] [--query-mode] [--query QUERY] [--query-type QUERY-TYPE] [--query-func QUERY-FUNC] [--query-only-one] [--query-trim] [--query-strip] [--query-interpolate] [--query-type-comment QUERY-TYPE-COMMENT] [--query-func-comment QUERY-FUNC-COMMENT] [--query-delimiter QUERY-DELIMITER] [--query-fields QUERY-FIELDS] [--escape-all] [--escape-schema] [--escape-table] [--escape-column] [--enable-postgres-oids] [--name-conflict-suffix NAME-CONFLICT-SUFFIX] [--template-path TEMPLATE-PATH] DSN

positional arguments:
  dsn                    data source name

options:
  --verbose, -v          toggle verbose
  --schema SCHEMA, -s SCHEMA
                         schema name to generate Go types for
  --out OUT, -o OUT      output path or file name
  --append, -a           append to existing files
  --suffix SUFFIX, -f SUFFIX
                         output file suffix [default: .gendal.go]
  --single-file          toggle single file output
  --package PACKAGE, -p PACKAGE
                         package name used in generated Go code
  --custom-type-package CUSTOM-TYPE-PACKAGE, -C CUSTOM-TYPE-PACKAGE
                         Go package name to use for custom or unknown types
  --int32-type INT32-TYPE, -i INT32-TYPE
                         Go type to assign to integers [default: int]
  --uint32-type UINT32-TYPE, -u UINT32-TYPE
                         Go type to assign to unsigned integers [default: uint]
  --ignore-fields IGNORE-FIELDS
                         fields to exclude from the generated Go code types
  --ignore-tables IGNORE-TABLES
                         tables to exclude from the generated Go code types
  --fk-mode FK-MODE, -k FK-MODE
                         sets mode for naming foreign key funcs in generated Go code [values: <smart|parent|field|key>] [default: smart]
  --use-index-names, -j
                         use index names as defined in schema for generated Go code
  --use-reversed-enum-const-names, -R
                         use reversed enum names for generated consts in Go code
  --query-mode, -N       enable query mode
  --query QUERY, -Q QUERY
                         query to generate Go type and func from
  --query-type QUERY-TYPE, -T QUERY-TYPE
                         query's generated Go type
  --query-func QUERY-FUNC, -F QUERY-FUNC
                         query's generated Go func name
  --query-only-one, -1   toggle query's generated Go func to return only one result
  --query-trim, -M       toggle trimming of query whitespace in generated Go code
  --query-strip, -B      toggle stripping type casts from query in generated Go code
  --query-interpolate, -I
                         toggle query interpolation in generated Go code
  --query-type-comment QUERY-TYPE-COMMENT
                         comment for query's generated Go type
  --query-func-comment QUERY-FUNC-COMMENT
                         comment for query's generated Go func
  --query-delimiter QUERY-DELIMITER, -D QUERY-DELIMITER
                         delimiter for query's embedded Go parameters [default: %%]
  --query-fields QUERY-FIELDS, -Z QUERY-FIELDS
                         comma separated list of field names to scan query's results to the query's associated Go type
  --escape-all, -X       escape all names in SQL queries
  --escape-schema, -z    escape schema name in SQL queries
  --escape-table, -y     escape table names in SQL queries
  --escape-column, -x    escape column names in SQL queries
  --enable-postgres-oids
                         enable postgres oids
  --name-conflict-suffix NAME-CONFLICT-SUFFIX, -w NAME-CONFLICT-SUFFIX
                         suffix to append when a name conflicts with a Go variable [default: Val]
  --template-path TEMPLATE-PATH
                         user supplied template path
  --help, -h             display this help and exit

Using a Configuration File

A more consistent and repeatable way to run gendal throughout the life of a project is to use a configuration file. A base configuration file called gendal.toml is provided which uses the TOML language for providing configurable access to all of the command line options.

Follow these steps to use the configuration file:

1. Copy the gendal.toml file from the gendal repository to the root directory of your project.
2. Edit the DSN setting to point to the database for your project.
3. Edit other settings according to the the needs of your project.
4. Run gendal without needing to pass any command line flags.

$ gendal

If any command line options are passed then they will override the setting provided in the configuration file.

About Base Templates

gendal provides a set of generic "base" templates for each of the supported databases, but it is understood these templates are not suitable for every organization or every schema out there. As such, you can author your own custom templates, or modify the base templates available in the gendal source tree, and use those with gendal by a passing a directory path via the --template-path flag.

For non-trivial schemas, custom templates are the most practical, common, and best way to use gendal (see below quickstart and related example).

Custom Template Quickstart

The following is a quick overview of copying the base templates contained in the gendal project's templates/ directory, editing to suit, and using with gendal:

# change to working project directory
$ cd $GOPATH/src/path/to/my/project

# create a template directory
$ mkdir -p templates

# copy gendal templates for postgres
$ cp "$GOPATH/src/github.com/turnkey-commerce/gendal/templates/*" templates/

# remove gendal binary data
$ rm templates/*.go

# edit base postgres templates
$ vi templates/postgres.*.tpl.go

# use with gendal
$ gendal pgsql://user:pass@host/db -o models --template-path templates

See the Custom Template example below for more information on adapting the base templates in the gendal source tree for use within your own project.

Storing Project Templates

Ideally, the custom templates for your project/schema should be stored within your project, and used in conjunction with a build pipeline such as go generate:

# add to custom gendal command to go generate:
$ tee -a gen.go << ENDGO
package mypackage

//go:generate gendal pgsql://user:pass@host/db -o models --template-path templates
ENDGO

# run go generate
$ go generate

# add custom templates and gen.go to project
$ git add templates gen.go && git commit -m 'Adding custom gendal templates for models'

Note that gendal only needs the templates for your specific database. You can safely delete the templates for the other databases -- make sure, however, that your templates are not symlinks to another database's templates before deleting.

Template Language/Syntax

gendal templates are standard Go text templates. Please see the documentation for Go's standard text/template package for information concerning the syntax, logic, and variable use within Go templates.

Template Context and File Layout

The contexts (ie, the . identifier in templates) made available to custom templates are instances of gendal/internal/$TYPE (see below table on $TYPE available $TYPEs), and are defined in internal/types.go.

Each database, $DBNAME, has its own set of templates for $TYPE and are available in the templates/ directory as templates/$DBNAME.$TYPE.go.tpl:

Template File	$TYPE	Description
templates/$DBNAME.type.go.tpl	Type	Template for schema tables/views/queries
templates/$DBNAME.enum.go.tpl	Enum	Template for schema enum definitions
templates/$DBNAME.proc.go.tpl	Proc	Template for stored procedures/functions ("routines")
templates/$DBNAME.foreignkey.go.tpl	ForeignKey	Template for foreign keys relationships
templates/$DBNAME.index.go.tpl	Index	Template for schema indexes
templates/$DBNAME.querytype.go.tpl	QueryType	Template for a custom query's generated type
templates/$DBNAME.query.go.tpl	Query	Template for custom query execution
templates/xo_db.go.tpl	ArgType	Package level template generated once per package
templates/xo_package.go.tpl	ArgType	File header template generated once per file

For example, PostgreSQL has templates/postgres.foreignkey.go.tpl which defines the template used by gendal for PostgreSQL's foreign keys. This template will be called once for every foreign key relationship that gendal finds in a PostgreSQL schema, and each time the template will be passed a different internal.ForeignKey instance, populated fields for Name, Schema, etc., which are then available in the templates/postgres.foreignkey.go.tpl as template variables, and used similar to the following: {{ .Name }}, {{ .Schema }}, etc.

Since some of the templates are identical for the supported databases, the templates are not duplicated, but are instead symlinks in the gendal source tree. For example, templates/oracle.querytype.go.tpl is a symlink to templates/postgres.querytype.go.tpl.

Template Helpers

There is a set of well defined template helpers in internal/funcs.go that can assist with writing templated Go code / SQL. Please review how the base templates/ make use of helpers, and/or see the inline documentation for the respective helper func definitions.

Packing Templates

The base gendal templates are bin packed so that they are always available to the built gendal binary using go-bindata (via the tpl.sh script) and need to be regenerated/included in any changeset when submitting any template changes to the gendal project.

If you would like to distribute your own binary version of gendal with the included templates, simply modify the templates in the gendal source tree, run tpl.sh, and build as you normally would.

Alternatively, you can simply do the following:

$ go generate && go build

Examples

Example: End-to-End

Please see the booktest example for a full end-to-end example for each supported database, showcasing how to use a database schema with gendal, and the resulting code generated by gendal.

Additionally, please see the pokedex example for a demonstration of running gendal against a large schema. Please note that this example is a work in progress, and does not yet work properly with Microsoft SQL Server and Oracle databases, and has no documentation (for now) -- however it works very similarly to the booktest end-to-end example.

Example: Ignoring Fields

Sometimes you may wish to have the database manage the values of columns instead of having them managed by code generated by gendal. As such, when you need gendal to ignore fields for a database schema, you can use the --ignore-fields flag. For example, a common use case is to define a table with created_at and/or modified_at timestamps, where the database is responsible for setting column values on INSERT and UPDATE, respectively.

Consider the following PostgreSQL schema where a users table has a created_at and modified_at field, where created_at has a default value of now() and where modified_at is updated by a trigger on UPDATE:

CREATE TABLE users (
  id SERIAL PRIMARY KEY,
  name text NOT NULL DEFAULT '' UNIQUE,
  created_at timestamptz default now(),
  modified_at timestamptz default now(),
);

CREATE OR REPLACE FUNCTION update_modified_column() RETURNS TRIGGER AS $$
BEGIN
    NEW.modfified_at = now();
    RETURN NEW;
END;
$$ language 'plpgsql';

CREATE TRIGGER update_users_modtime BEFORE UPDATE ON users FROM EACH ROW EXECUTE PROCEDURE update_modified_column();

We can ensure that these columns are managed by PostgreSQL and not by the Go code generated with gendal by passing the --ignore-fields option:

# ignore special fields
$ gendal pgsql://user:pass@host/db -o models --ignore-fields created_at modified_at

Example: Custom Template -- adding a GetMostRecent lookup for all tables

Often, a schema has a common layout/pattern, such as every table having a created_at and modified_at field (as in the PostgreSQL schema in the previous example). It is then a common use-case to have a GetMostRecent lookup for each table type, retrieving the most recently modified rows for each table (up to some limit, N).

To accomplish this with gendal, we will need to create our own set of custom templates, and then add a GetMostRecent lookup to the $DBTYPE.type.go.tpl template.

First, we create a copy of the base gendal templates:

$ cd $GOPATH/src/path/to/project

$ mkdir -p templates

$ cp $GOPATH/src/github.com/turnkey-commerce/gendal/templates/* templates/

We can now modify the templates to suit our specific schema, adding lookups, helpers, or anything else necessary for our schema.

To add a GetMostRecent lookup, we edit our copy of the postgres.type.go.tpl template:

$ vi templates/postgres.type.go.tpl

And add the following templated GetMostRecent func at the end of the file:

// GetMostRecent{{ .Name }} returns n most recent rows from '{{ .Schema }}.{{ .Table.TableName }}',
// ordered by "created_at" in descending order.
func GetMostRecent{{ .Name }}(db XODB, n int) ([]*{{ .Name }}, error) {
    const sqlstr = `SELECT ` +
        `{{ colnames .Fields "created_at" "modified_at" }}` +
        `FROM {{ $table }} ` +
        `ORDER BY created_at DESC LIMIT $1`

    q, err := db.Query(sqlstr, n)
    if err != nil {
        return nil, err
    }
    defer q.Close()

    // load results
    var res []*{{ .Name }}
    for q.Next() {
        {{ $short }} := {{ .Name }}{}

        // scan
        err = q.Scan({{ fieldnames .Fields (print "&" $short) }})
        if err != nil {
            return nil, err
        }

        res = append(res, &{{ $short }})
    }

    return res, nil
}

We can then use the templates in conjunction with gendal to generate our "model" code:

$ gendal pgsql://user:pass@localhost/dbname -o models --template-path templates/

There will now be a GetMostRecentUsers func defined in models/user.gendal.go, which can be used as follows:

db, err := dburl.Open("pgsql//user:pass@localhost/dbname")
if err != nil { /* ... */ }

// retrieve 15 most recent items
mostRecentUsers, err := models.GetMostRecentUsers(db, 15)
if err != nil { /* ... */ }
for _, user := range users {
    log.Printf("got user: %+v", user)
}

Using SQL Drivers

Please note that the base gendal templates do not import any SQL drivers. It is left for the user of gendal's generated code to import the actual drivers. For reference, these are the expected drivers to use with the code generated by gendal:

Database (driver)	Package
Microsoft SQL Server (mssql)	github.com/denisenkom/go-mssqldb
MySQL (mysql)	github.com/go-sql-driver/mysql
Oracle (ora)	gopkg.in/rana/ora.v4
PostgreSQL (postgres)	github.com/lib/pq
CockroachDB (postgres)	github.com/lib/pq
SQLite3 (sqlite3)	github.com/mattn/go-sqlite3

Additionally, please see below for usage notes on specific SQL database drivers.

MySQL (mysql)

If your schema or custom query contains table or column names that need to be escaped using any of the --escape-* options, you must pass the sql_mode=ansi option to the MySQL driver:

$ gendal --escape-all 'mysql://user:pass@host/?parseTime=true&sql_mode=ansi' -o models

And when opening a database connection:

db, err := dburl.Open("mysql://user:pass@host/?parseTime=true&sql_mode=ansi")

Additionally, when working with date/time column types in MySQL, one should pass the parseTime=true option to the MySQL driver:

$ gendal 'mysql://user:pass@host/dbname?parseTime=true' -o models

And when opening a database connection:

db, err := dburl.Open("mysql://user:pass@host/dbname?parseTime=true")

Oracle (ora)

Oracle support is disabled by default as the Go Oracle driver used by gendal needs the Oracle instantclient libs to be installed/known by pkg-config. If you have already installed rana's Oracle driver according to the installation instructions, you can simply pass -tags oracle to go get, go install or go build to enable Oracle support:

$ go get -tags oracle -u github.com/turnkey-commerce/gendal

Installing Oracle instantclient on Debian/Ubuntu

On Ubuntu/Debian, you may download the instantclient RPMs here.

You should then be able to do the following:

# install alien, if not already installed
$ sudo aptitude install alien

# install the instantclient RPMs
$ sudo alien -i oracle-instantclient-12.1-basic-*.rpm
$ sudo alien -i oracle-instantclient-12.1-devel-*.rpm
$ sudo alien -i oracle-instantclient-12.1-sqlplus-*.rpm

# get gendal
$ go get -u github.com/turnkey-commerce/gendal

# copy oci8.pc from gendal/contrib to system pkg-config directory
$ sudo cp $GOPATH/src/github.com/turnkey-commerce/gendal/contrib/oci8.pc /usr/lib/pkgconfig/

# install rana's ora driver
$ go get -u gopkg.in/rana/ora.v4

# assuming the above succeeded, install gendal with oracle support enabled
$ go install -tags oracle github.com/turnkey-commerce/gendal

Contrib Scripts and Oracle Docker Image

It's of note that there are additional scripts available in the contrib directory that can help when working with Oracle databases and gendal.

For reference, the gendal developers use the sath89/oracle-12c Docker image for testing gendal's Oracle database support.

CockroachDB (postgres)

CockroachDB is a distributed SQL database that is basically wire-compatible with Postgres with exceptions in the supported features. The compatibility does allow to use the standard pg driver in Go.

If the database is named something other than 'public' it is necessary to provide the database name as the schema via the -s name argument when using gendal:

$ gendal cr://cr_user@localhost:26257/crdb?sslmode=disable -s crdb -o models

Note: The sslmode=disable is for development only and not for production.

SQLite3 (sqlite3)

While not required, one should specify the loc=auto option when using gendal with a SQLite3 database:

$ gendal 'file:mydatabase.sqlite3?loc=auto' -o models

And when opening a database connection:

db, err := dburl.Open("file:mydatabase.sqlite3?loc=auto")

About Primary Keys

For row inserts gendal determines whether the primary key is automatically generated by the DB or must be provided by the application for the table row being inserted. For example a table that has a primary key that is also a foreign key to another table, or a table that has multiple primary keys in a many-to-many link table, it is desired that the application provide the primary key(s) for the insert rather than the DB.

gendal will query the schema to determine if the database provides an automatic primary key and if the table does not provide one then it will require that the application provide the primary key for the object passed to the the Insert method. Below is information on how the logic works for each database type to determine if the DB automatically provides the PK.

MySQL Auto PK Logic

• Checks for an autoincrement row in the information_schema for the table in question.

PostgreSQL Auto PK Logic

• Checks for a sequence that is owned by the table in question.

CockroachDB Auto PK Logic

• Checks for table with a column with a constraint that is named 'primary'.
• Checks that the column in question has a default value of 'unique_rowid()'.

SQLite Auto PK Logic

• Checks the SQL that is used to generate the table contains the AUTOINCREMENT keyword.
• Checks that the table was created with the primary key type of INTEGER.

If either of the above conditions are satisfied then the PK is determined to be automatically provided by the DB. For the case of integer PK's when you want to override that the PK be manually provided then you can define the key type as INT instead of INTEGER, for example as in the following many-to-many link table:

  CREATE TABLE "SiteContacts" (
  "ContactId"	INT NOT NULL,
  "SiteId"	INT NOT NULL,
  PRIMARY KEY(ContactId,SiteId),
  FOREIGN KEY("ContactId") REFERENCES "Contacts" ( "ContactId" ),
  FOREIGN KEY("SiteId") REFERENCES "Sites" ( "SiteId" )
)

SQL Server Auto PK Logic

• Checks for an identity associated with one of the columns for the table in question.

Oracle Auto PK Logic

There is currently no method provided for Oracle as there is no programmatic way to query for which sequences are associated with tables. All PK's will be assumed to be provided by the database.

Design, Origin, Philosophy, and History

gendal can likely get you 99% "of the way there" on medium or large database schemas and 100% of the way there for small or trivial database schemas. In short, gendal is a great launching point for developing standardized packages for standard database abstractions/relationships, and gendal's most common use-case is indeed in a code generation pipeline, ala stringer.

Design

gendal is NOT designed to be an ORM or to generate an ORM. Instead, gendal is designed to vastly reduce the overhead/redundancy of (re-)writing types and funcs for common database queries/relationships in Go -- it is not meant to be a "silver bullet".

History

The xo project was originally developed while migrating a large application written in PHP to Go. The schema in use in the original app, while well designed, had become inconsistent over multiple iterations/generations, mainly due to different naming styles adopted by various developers/database admins over the preceding years. Additionally, some components had been written in different languages (Ruby, Java) and had also accumulated significant drift from the original application and accompanying schema. Simultaneously, a large amount of growth meant that the PHP/Ruby code could no longer efficiently serve the traffic volumes.

In late 2014/early 2015, a decision was made to unify and strip out certain backend services and to fully isolate the API from the original application, allowing the various components to instead speak to a common API layer instead of directly to the database, and to build that service layer in Go.

However, unraveling the old PHP/Ruby/Java code became a large headache, as the code, the database, and the API, all had significant drift -- thus, underlying function names, fields, and API methods no longer coincided with the actual database schema, and were named differently in each language. As such, after a round of standardizing names, dropping cruft, and adding a small number of relationship changes to the schema, the various codebases were fixed to match the schema changes. After that was determined to be a success, the next target was to rewrite the backend services in Go.

In order to keep a similar and consistent workflow for the developers, the previous code generator (written in PHP and Twig templates) was modified to generate Go code. Additionally, at this time, but tangential to the story, the API definitions were ported from JSON to Protobuf to make use of its code generation abilities as well.

gendal is based on the open source version of that code generation tool, and is the fruits of those development efforts. It is hoped that others will be able to use and expand gendal to support other databases -- SQL or otherwise -- and that gendal can become a common tool in any Go developer's toolbox.

Goals

Part of gendal's goals is to avoid writing an ORM, or an ORM-like in Go, and to instead generate static, type-safe, fast, and idiomatic Go code across languages and databases. Additionally, the gendal developers are of the opinion that relational databases should have proper, well-designed relationships and all the related definitions should reside within the database schema itself: ie, a "self-documenting" schema. gendal is an end to that pursuit.

Related Projects

• dburl - a Go package providing a standard, URL style mechanism for parsing and opening database connection URLs
• usql - a universal command-line interface for SQL databases

Other Projects

The following projects work with similar concepts as gendal:

Go Generators

• ModelQ
• squirrel

Go ORM-likes

• sqlc

TODO

• Fix issues and act on pull requests (PRIORITY #1)
• Add (finish) stored proc support for Oracle + Microsoft SQL Server
• Unit tests / code coverage / continuous builds for binary package releases
• Move database introspection to separate package for reuse by other Go packages
• Overhaul/standardize type parsing
• Finish support for --{incl, excl}[ude] types
• Write/publish template set for protobuf
• Add support for generating models for other languages
• Finish many-to-many and link table support
• Finish example and code for generated *Slice types (also, only generate for the databases its needed for)
• Add example for many-to-many relationships and link tables
• Add support for supplying a file (ie, *.sql) for query generation
• Add support for full text types (tsvector, tsquery on PostgreSQL)
• Finish COMMENT support for PostgreSQL/MySQL and update templates accordingly.
• Add support for JSON types (json, jsonb on PostgreSQL, json on MySQL)
• Add support for GIN index queries (PostgreSQL)

License

This project is licensed under the MIT License. See the LICENSE file for the full text.

Acknowledgements

gendal is based on a fork of the xo repository maintained by Kenneth Shaw.

• Contributors